Friday 20 October 2017

The Technic Boards

I admit to being less interested in the military manoeuvres at the climax of Poul Anderson's "The Big Rain." However, here is something that I skipped over earlier. Anyone who wants to enter the government on Venus must:

pass a series of rigid tests;
go through years of apprenticeship and of exhaustive study;
accept gradual promotions on the recommendations of seniors.

The study is of:

history;
psycho-technics (a science);
physical science.

"...in principle, thought Hollister, remembering some of the blubberheads who  still got themselves elected at home, a good idea."
-Poul Anderson, "The Big Rain" IN Anderson, The Psychotechnic League (New York, 1981), pp. 201-280 AT p. 209.

Not a  good idea. It has been suggested that a politician should have a degree in politics just as a doctor has a degree in medicine and Heinlein suggested mathematical tests for voters. Experts who either advise governments or implement government policies should have appropriate qualifications but a government itself should consist of elected and, in my opinion, recallable representatives. Every citizen should be not only informed but also able either to speak publicly or to accept the representative role for a longer or shorter period. That would require a different educational system. There is a difference between social policies, e.g., to eliminate hunger and homelessness, and technical knowledge, e.g., how to grow crops and build houses.

Hollister is surprised that the governing boards are so small, without "...an omnipresent bureaucracy." (ibid.) Then he remembers that the boards are served by electronic files and computers. Not only dictatorships but also democracies can use information technology to eliminate bureaucracy. Are there unhoused citizens in one city and empty buildings in another? The solution is simple.

3 comments:

S.M. Stirling said...

Simple solutions generally aren't, unless some means exist to forcibly simplify matters. Eg., armies and prisons don't have homelessness problems, but that isn't necessarily a good thing.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Mr Stirling,
I should have said that the solution is simple if there is the collective will for it - not otherwise!
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

And I don't expect there to ever be any kind of "ideal" political system of the kind you hope for. Because human beings are HUMAN, they will fight and compete for power, for instance.

And some of the states of the US have special elections for "recalling" politicians. It has NOT worked as its original advocates hoped. It has become just another device or method used in PARTISAN political struggles. Usually by a defeated party seeking revenge for losing an election. For example, the Democrats, enraged at losing to Gov. Scott Walker and the policies he advocated, twice tried to oust him from office by using recall elections. They failed both times.

Sean